Yearning Blue
  • Home
  • Local Poet
  • Local Artist
  • Publications
  • Me and the Family
    • The Family >
      • Family News 1998
      • Family News 1999
      • Family News 2000
      • Family News 2001
      • Family News 2002
      • Family News 2004
      • Family News 2006
      • Family News 2007
      • Family News 2008
      • Family News 2009
      • Family News 2010
      • Family News 2011
      • Family News 2012
      • Family News 2013
      • Family News 2014
      • Family News 2015
      • Family News 2016
      • Family News 2017
  • Poems
    • The View from the Hilltop
    • Winter Sun
    • Thoughts at a wedding
    • Come dance with me.
    • Seasons of Love
    • Last weeks red roses
    • Christmas Surprise
    • The Sound of Christmas
    • A Grace
    • Worship in the Woods
    • Noses
    • Purpose
    • How many bananas?
    • Arthur
  • Short Stories
    • Interviews with a Magician
    • The First Lesson of Magic
    • Mariad's Island
    • Matts Dragon
    • Dry Murder
    • All the Dead of Morne
    • The Fish
    • Shadowskin
    • Up the Mountain
    • A Man to Fear
    • A Scene of Crimes
    • The Weather Says It All.
    • Autumn Girl
    • Out of Hadra
    • The Art of Dying
  • Flash Fiction
    • Androidism
    • Walking Oddbins
    • Homecoming
    • A beach, at dawn
    • Schrodinger's Door
    • The Seagull's Return
  • Novels
    • Can of Worms
    • The Empresses Lover
  • Carbunkle Hall
  • Projects
    • The Tethane
    • A Voyage in Jade
    • The Hidden Libraries
    • Princess
  • My Best Reads
    • Best Reads 2012
    • Best Reads 2013
    • Best Reads 2014
    • Best Reads 2015
    • Best Reads 2016
    • Best Reads 2017
    • Best Reads 2018
  • Photography
  • Links
  • Contact me
  • The Reality Escape Committee

I, Daniel Blake

28/10/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
I saw Ken Loach's latest film this evening, and having seen it, I would like to put Ken Loach out of business

I don't say this because he is bad at his job. On the contrary, he is brilliant (and so is his screenwriter!). He takes a mundane account of a middle-aged man with heart trouble claiming benefits and looking for work and makes it utterly absorbing. No action sequences, no special effects, no stunning scenery. Just people in homes and shops and offices, going about their lives, and it's riveting.

Daniel Blake is the central character. An ordinary bloke, a carpenter with a lifetime of steady graft behind him, a heart attack leaves him unfit for work. But as the film begins (black screen initially, with just a conversation being heard – a surprisingly effective (and funny!) way of introducing the story – the interview by a 'health care professional' (not a doctor or a nurse, as is made clear) leads to him being assessed as 'fit for work'.

And things go downhill from there, as Daniel finds himself in constant conflict with a system that is both inefficient and inflexible, and which leaves no space for simple human compassion. Even the DWP employee who tries to help Daniel navigate the computer system finds herself in trouble.

What came over to me most strongly from the film was the sheer frustration of trying to get someone just to listen to a few simple facts. That, and the sense of being ground down by a vast weight of bureaucracy.

But, awful though the situation was, I didn't find it unremittingly bleak. What makes the film so watchable – what makes Daniel's situation bearable – is that in the midst of the bureaucratic nightmare there are still moments of friendship and humour, warmth and compassion. Daniel himself is the best example of that. Though the system is trying to crush him, he still manages to reach out and offer help to others who are struggling. And one of the most moving parts for me is where he talks about his dead wife, and we get a glimpse of the relationship that made him the man he is.

So why do I want to put Ken Loach out of business?

Not because I disagree with him about the injustices of our Welfare system. Not because I think he has misrepresented either the people or the situations. But precisely because he's right about these things – but he shouldn't be! These things should not exist. We should not need food banks to enable people to get by. Young women should not be driven to prostitution in order to provide for their children. Men with heart conditions should not be forced to go looking for jobs that they aren't allowed to take for medical reasons.

Ken Loach should be put out of business by a fair, just, compassionate system that treats people with respect and values them for who they are, not for their economic productivity. He would then have to direct his considerable talents to documentaries about nature or art or something innocuous.

But that's not likely to happen – certainly not while so many prefer to keep their heads firmly in the sand rather than admit that the system which is meant to help people is very often destroying them.

So I expect and hope that he will continue to make films, and that others will come forward with films or plays or articles or novels or any other means of communication and remind us all again and again what it's like to be caught up in the bureaucratic machinery of the State.

And if they can't fix the system, perhaps they can at least inspire us to face it with the courage, humour and compassion of Daniel Blake.


0 Comments
    Picture

    Paul Trembling

    Husband, father, dog owner, Christian, writer, and incurable daydreamer.  In no particular order of importance - they are all me.

    Welcome to my blog, where I will attempt to document my small corner of reality, and my attempts to escape from it.

    Archives

    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    July 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    November 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012

    Categories

    All
    2012
    2013
    Best Reads
    Bible
    Bristol
    Crime
    Daily Life
    Fathers
    Film
    God
    Kindle
    Memories
    Monologue
    New Book
    Noah
    Poem
    Prayer
    Reality
    Rwanda
    Speculation
    Suffering
    Time
    Traffic
    Trinity
    Writing

    RSS Feed

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from h.koppdelaney, BitterScripts, psicologiaclinica, x-ray delta one, Erik Daniel Drost, jonny goldstein, guzzphoto, inkknife_2000 (5 million views), Coletivo Mambembe, Doctor_Q, tmib_seattle, Howdy, I'm H. Michael Karshis, h.koppdelaney, Menage a Moi, Click*64, Su Bee Buzz!, Susan WD, World Around Richa, h.koppdelaney, gavin.lauchlan, garrettc, polandeze, Alan Cleaver